A housing bubble in hong kong won\t topple its economy. Abstract this study attempt to provide an empirical answer to a question that most hong kong citizen concerns. Detecting bubbles in hong kong residential property market. Hong kong, chinas housing market witnessed dramatic appreciations. Lets take a look at how chinas housing bubble grew. Hong kongs robust public finances are outweighed by concern of a propertyprice bubble, with worries about real estate and overall inflation coming to the. Nov 29, 2006 this study investigates whether there was a housing price bubble in beijing and shanghai in 2003. A housing bubble is what happens when housing prices go up, up, up, rising like a soap bubble on a summer breeze. Sep 11, 20 how will rising rates impact residential real estate. Today, most people would acknowledge that the recovery in home prices has been more than reasonable.
Data for rent were downloaded from the taipei online enquiry system for. Despite attempts by the government to curb hong kong s housing market, prices continued to climb this year as demand outpaced supply. Avoiding a housing price bubble in hong kong nasdaq. Consider real house price growth in the g7 economies over the last two cycles 20012007 and 20102017. Nov 02, 2015 chinas housing market, unlike the bubble market in the u. However, identifying whether or not chinas housing market is in the midst of a bubble is even harder, due to the young nature of chinas housing market. The financial services firms annual global real estate bubble index named favored chinese homebuying destination vancouver as the global city most at risk for a housing bubble, with london, sydney and hong kong all landing among the top six most distorted markets in. The dilemma of real estate market in mainland china core. Thats according to the sobering 60 minutes segment bricks and slaughter which aired last night, revealing the countrys property downturn was just the tip of the iceberg. Taking things a step further, the economist recently went so far as to call the global housing boom the biggest bubble in history. Changes in property prices and rents influence consumer price inflation, and affect. This thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the department of economics at digital. Household incomes and house prices in balance in the long term.
Selected property market related policies in hong kong. Free market policies transformed hong kong from a city of refugees. Housing price bubbles in hong kong, beijing and shanghai. Beginning around 2003, chinas erstwhile premier, wen jiabao, started to encourage chinas banks to provide cheap credit for individuals and companies hoping to build or buy new property. Thats according to the sobering 60 minutes segment bricks and slaughter which aired last night, revealing the. None of these explanations, however, is capable of fully explaining the housing bubble. First, it demonstrates that the bubble was a supplyside phenomenon, attributable to an excess of mispriced mortgage finance. The driving forces behind the recent housing market development in. Lowdown payment mortgages inflated housing prices because buyers could afford a. A housing bubble is a runup in housing prices fueled by demand, speculation and exuberance. Hong kong popping housing bubbles london cant handle bloomberg. This article posits a new explanation for the housing bubble.
Hong kong s unaffordable housing is the stuff of legend, but some analysts see signs the property bubble s days are numbered. Pdf burst of the property bubble and hong kongs changing land. Housing market corrections from bubble highs can take a very long time and can be very deep. Mar 29, 20 but at the rate prices are rising, hong kong is the biggest housing bubble market around. The result was a house price bubble of unprecedented magnitude. Take a look at the worlds dizzying surges in the price of housing for 12 months at the end of june. This study investigates whether there was a housing price bubble in beijing and shanghai in 2003.
Our empirical results reveal several positive bubbles in the hong kong residential property market, including one in 1995, a stronger one in 1997, yet another one in 2004, and a more recent one in 2008. A housing bubble in hong kong won\ t topple its economy the city\s home prices have risen by some % after hitting a bottom in mid2014. Whilst house prices have risen well above the rate of inflation, in general the scale is much less than prior to the financial crisis. The uncertainty surrounding chinas housing bubble world. Analysts at ubs pointed to hong kongs recordhigh home pricetoincome ratio, and high home price to rent ratio, as indicators that the city has a distinct risk of a housing bubble. Jun 20, 2017 housing market corrections from bubble highs can take a very long time and can be very deep. Law, economics and finance of the real estate market a. Dropping interest rates, in a misguided attempt to encourage the sort of investment that would actually increase wealth, has only served to divert the savings of the haves into property. Whereas in other sectors identifying a bubble can be achieved by looking at historic data, this is not possible with chinas housing market. As the housing market crashed, residentialconstructionrelated employment fell substantially. How will rising rates impact residential real estate. A buying frenzy has been encouraged, a race to get on the propertyasset ladder while the bubble is still inflating.
A comparative study of private housing price between hong. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading rethinking housing bubbles. Hong kong has one of the largest public housing sectors in the world. Hong kong popping housing bubbles london cant handle. These rising prices are fueled by demand, which is in turn driven by speculation prices are expected to keep going up and up indefinitely, so everyone wants to buy a home right away before the prices go even higher. Wall street and the housing bubble inghaw cheng, sahil raina, wei xiong.
Housing bubbles usually start with an increase in demand, in the face of limited supply. Chinoh chang, mingchi chen, chihy uan yang 2010, reexamination of t aipei housing bubbles, taiwan real estate center. The housing bubble blog a buying frenzy has been encouraged. Lowdown payment mortgages inflated housing prices because buyers could afford a larger house with the same down payment. Las vegas also experienced a bubble when housing prices rose 30 percent year over year because.
If hong kong isnt a housing bubble, then nothing is. There have, of course, been any number of doomsday predictions in the past that didnt come true. The biggest housing bubble in history created by chinas rapid growth and the massive investment in real estate by its burgeoning middle class may be about to burst. This study uses a newly developed bubble detection method phillips, shi, and yu, 2011 to identify real estate bubbles in the hong kong residential property market. January 27, 2016 with the economy going strong and the fed raising rates, nobody really wants to talk. Jan 20, 2015 the result was a house price bubble of unprecedented magnitude. Our empirical results reveal several positive bubbles in the hong kong residential property market, including one in. From a macroeconomic perspective, it is reassuring. But at the rate prices are rising, hong kong is the biggest housing bubble market around. In the context of financial crises influenced by the development and burst of housing price bubbles, the detection of exuberant behaviors in the financial market and the. Jul 30, 2014 take a look at the worlds dizzying surges in the price of housing for 12 months at the end of june. Decrease in wealth from housing caused a decrease in aggregate demand lead to a financial crisis which made things work before thinking about the bubble, we need to worry about the financial markets behind housing and housing.
This paper introduces an enhanced framework, with the combination of standard econometric methodologies. This study uses a newly developed bubble detection method phillips, shi and yu, 2011 to identify real estate bubbles in the hong kong residential property market. According to the survey, which covered 15 cities globally, average home prices in hong kong are now 21 times average annual incomes far exceeding the 14to1. Why hong kongs property bubble looks set to deflate cnbc. Now, hong kong has a housing bubble to beat all housing bubbles. Hong kong s robust public finances are outweighed by concern of a propertyprice bubble, with worries about real estate and overall inflation coming to the. In the meantime, you can learn more about this bubble in our emerging markets bubble report.
The role of household and bank balance sheets in modeling economic cycles kindle edition by gjerstad, steven d. A comparative study article in the journal of real estate finance and economics 334. Housing and the bubble the housing bubble is one of the main causes of the current downturn for two reasons. Chinas housing market, unlike the bubble market in the u. Acomparativestudyof privatehousingpricebetweenhong kongandworldwidemajorcountries 4. Government created the housing bubble and financial crisis. Housing policies in hong kong, china and the peoples republic of.
The role of household and bank balance sheets in modeling. The affordability ratio and pricetoincome ratio and panic buying. Despite attempts by the government to curb hong kongs housing market, prices continued to climb this year as demand outpaced supply. Housing prices rose 11 percent this year, and colliers internat. London and hong kong facing housing bubble risk, ubs says. Pdf housing prices in hong kong have gained international attention.
Hong kong, china favors the elderly and the poor, thus housing policies tend to. Ten years from the last crash, is another global housing. London and hong kong are the cities most at risk of a housing bubble as real estate begins to look overvalued, according to ubs group ag. The existence of a bubble can be interpreted from abnormal interactions between housing prices and market fundamentals. First, it demonstrates that the bubble was a supplyside phenomenon attributable to an. This affordability problem is common for every housing bubble. What keeps a bubble alive in an ordinary city is the fact that people simply do not want to move away from their hometown just to save money. A burst in the housing bubble, a sharp drop in the stock market or a recession could prompt foreigners to cut back on u. Senior advisor in the imfs asia and pacific department. In our march 2012 investment strategy update, housing the bubble, the collapse, the recovery. Hong kongs unaffordable housing is the stuff of legend, but some analysts see signs the property bubbles days are numbered. Is the housing price in hong kong nowadays irrationally high. Ojedajoya catalina reyguerra natalia sicard abstract.
960 1483 1028 864 48 1249 1218 1351 1200 1118 1343 499 523 811 1016 288 1194 172 315 1223 1196 1187 1351 276 334 62 392 798 1139 1477 1209 352